What evidence did Courtney Clenny's defense team present to support her version of events?

The defense built its case on three concrete pieces of evidence. First, they conducted a forensic experiment using a pig carcass — someone threw a knife at it — and argued that the resulting angle and wound depth were consistent with Clenny's account. Second, they introduced Miami Police Department body cam video recorded just days before Christian Obamsele's death, showing Clenny at a police station requesting a restraining order against him. Third, they presented footage from a neighbor who stated that one week before the stabbing, he witnessed Obamsele punch Clenny.

Each piece of evidence served a distinct function. The pig carcass experiment directly challenged the prosecution's narrative: the medical examiner had concluded that the wound was too deep to be consistent with a knife thrown from approximately 10 feet away, which is the distance Clenny told detectives she was standing. The defense used the experiment to offer an alternative physical explanation — that a thrown knife could produce exactly that depth of injury.

The body cam footage and the neighbor's account worked together to establish a documented pattern of domestic violence before April 3rd, 2022. By showing that Clenny had formally sought police protection against Obamsele just days earlier, and that an independent witness had seen him be physically violent toward her a week before his death, the defense framed the stabbing not as an act of premeditated violence but as the culmination of an abusive relationship. You can hear the full episode breakdown on Listenly's Dateline NBC page.